Folk artist Gary Granada is asking for the support of fellow artists to join him in his crusade against the GMA Kapuso Foundation for allegedly "stealing" an original idea and disregarding the law concerning intellectual property rights.
In an audio file now proliferating in cyberspace, Gary narrated how he was tapped by the foundation in partnership with multinational company Procter & Gamble to write and arrange a jingle for the "Tripid Handog Edukasyon" campaign.
"Gaya ng nakasanayan sa advertising industry, binigyan nila ako ng lyrics which I'm supposed to set to music na dapat ang haba ay 60 seconds," said the singer-songwriter, whose popular mainstream compositions include "‘Pag Nanalo ang Ginebra" and "Mabuti Pa Sila," among others.
As a songwriter commissioned to lend his expertise to a project, Gary pointed out his right to tweak and change a few, or if necessary, a number of lines he felt necessary to fit the melody he had in mind.
The final study submitted by Gary, unfortunately, was turned down thus allowing the client to scout for other composers who might meet their vision for the project. A seasoned songwriter well versed on the business side of the entire trade, Gary reiterated he has no problem dealing with his client's final judgment whether to accept or reject his proposal.
A COLLECTIVE EFFORT? The problem started when Gary heard the approved jingle played on the airwaves purportedly done by a different composer.
Gary claimed that the version used by his former clients resembles the "rejected" study he initially submitted.
"Obviously, ginamit nila ‘yong edited lyrics batay sa pagkasukat ko," he took note. "Pero hindi lang po ‘yon ‘yong issue. Bukod sa lyrics, ginamit din nilang tungtungan ang musical structure na ginawa ko."
Gary continued, "Nagsumbong ako sa FILSCAP, ‘yon po yong Filipino Society of Composers Authors and Publishers. Nagpadala ito ng sulat sa GMA. Tinanong namin kung bakit di nila ginawa ‘yong friendly reminder namin na kung ipagawa nila sa iba, ang ibigay nila sa gagawa ay ang original nilang lyrics at huwag gamitin ang ginawa kong study."
The letter containing the points raised by Gary and FILSCAP reportedly fell on deaf ears, which the songsmith labeled as an "arrogant" gesture on GMA-7 part.
Gary likewise lashed out at the network's legal team for its statement challenging his argument by saying that the material was a collective effort, meaning that Gary has no right to claim sole ownership of the idea, more importantly the lyrics used for the jingle.
"Kung ganun, e, di ang ibig sabihin pala, kung paano sinukat ‘yong lyrics at music para magkasya sa isang minuto ay collective namin ginawa ‘yon. 'Yong paano pagtugmain ‘yong mga letra sa mga nota ay collective namin ginawa ‘yon. 'Yong kung saan dalhin ang daloy ng harmony ay collective namin ginawa 'yon. At kung ganun na nga, marami naman pala sa GMA Network that can collectively compose, bakit pa nila ako kinuha?
"Sa tinagal-tagal ko sa trabahong ito, noon ko lang naranasan ang mag-compose collectively. Naalala ko ‘yong short meeting namin na ‘yon, mahaba kasi ‘yong lyrics kaya kailangan pang paiksiin. Halimbawa, ‘yong ‘aking kinabukasan' ok ba sa inyo kung gawin kong ‘bukas aking kinabukasan,' pitong syllables. ‘Bukas' dalawa lang, tatango-tango naman ‘yong iba. Ganun pala ‘yong mag-compose collectively," Gary said sarcastically.





Stick to what is being discussed. Mr. Granada is the aggrieved party. I-try nyo kaya mag create ng song or anything na galing sayo and then kopyahin ng iba claiming that it was theirs in the first place. Hindi ba kayo ma -offend? The fact that pinaghirapan nya yon pero binabalewala lang---NAKAKAINSULTO...Magbasa naman kayo ng Intellectual Property Rights.
Ney
February 3, 2009
07:48 AM
kasimpleng english di maintindihan ng mga kapalmilya lol.
makatira lang sa GMA hahahaha.
-----
Korek ka jan ahahahha. kung ano ano nalang ang mga pinag sasasabi halatang di naintindihan yung mga binasa. Well palibhasa english ahahahhahahah
tenbananas
February 3, 2009
06:27 AM
_________
remember that in every law, there is always an exception...
redprince
February 3, 2009
07:29 AM
________
para kasing bombang sumabog mismo sa harapan nila ang balita.. ayan ang akala nilang mabait na gma e may tinatagong lihim din.. yan ang sinasabi ko pa dati pa na lahat naman ng network e may lihim .. ang iba kasi sa atin masyadong nagpaniwalang di gagawa ng kasamaan ang kanilang network.. ayan tuloy, hanggang ngaun e indenial pa rin sila..
This is a case between Mr. Granada and Gma Marketing Ad
it has nothing to do with panlabas na anyo...ikaw kaya ang magcompose ng song kung kaya mo!our family knows GG magkapitbahay kami...mabubuting tao family nila at lahing mga smart pa!!!
walng kang K magsabi nag ganyan....
makatira lang sa GMA hahahaha.
at talagang pinagtanggol nyo pa ang GMA?
grabe na ito. nasa utak nyo na talaga ang network wars?
uy. hindi na ABS-CBN ang kalaban ng GMA sa pagkakataong ito.
maiintindihan ko pa kung ABS pa. Or nung dinemanda ng GMA ang TV5.
GMA provided the lyrics. Yun naman pala, eh!
basahin mo na lang Gary and decision ng korte sa Erickson vs. Trinity Theater, 13F, 3d 1106, 1994.